If you’re a writer, chances are you’ve had this happen: you’re elbow-deep in your current book, the one that’s supposed to be your sole focus, and suddenly, bam!, three new story ideas start fighting for attention in your brain. Each one feels like it’s the one, and your creative energy starts splintering in every direction.
Trust me, I’ve been there. In fact, I’m there right now. While I’m working on the third book in my Starting Over Trilogy, I’ve got three new story concepts swirling around in my head, each with its own set of characters, plot twists, and emotional arcs demanding to be heard.
The problem? If I don’t capture those ideas when they happen, they’ll vanish as quickly as they appeared. But if I stop writing entirely to chase every thought, my current project suffers.
That’s where my favorite technique comes in: step away for a short while and document just enough of those new ideas to keep them alive.
Why It Helps to Step Away (Briefly)
Taking a short creative pause doesn’t derail your focus. It preserves it. Think of it as hitting “save” on your imagination. When your brain is juggling multiple ideas, it’s easy to feel scattered, but taking an hour to outline the basics of a new story can actually free up your mind to refocus on your current work.
One book that backs this idea beautifully is The Net and the Butterfly: The Art and Practice of Breakthrough Thinking. The authors explain that our best ideas often strike at inconvenient times: when we’re in the shower, driving, or just waking up. That’s because our minds are relaxed and open to connection. The trick isn’t to ignore those moments, but to capture them before they drift away.
How I Capture My “Future Books”
Here’s the process that works for me whenever inspiration tries to crash my writing schedule:
1. Write a preliminary story synopsis
I treat it like an extended elevator pitch. Just a paragraph or two that answers: What’s this story about, and why does it matter? This not only keeps the idea fresh, but it also gives me something to share later if I want feedback from friends, critique partners, or my editor.
2. Define the setting
Where (and when) does this story unfold? Sometimes I know the geography right away—say, a coastal Maine town or a small Minnesota suburb. Other times, I just know the tone: contemporary, small-town, or maybe a near-future twist. Setting helps anchor the story in my mind so it doesn’t feel like vapor.
3. List out the characters
I jot down names, relationships, and quirks. They don’t have to be fully formed, just memorable enough to recognize when I revisit the file months later. For instance, in the book I’m writing now, one of my characters is obsessed with zombie books and movies. It’s a tiny detail that adds color to her personality, and I might’ve forgotten it completely if I hadn’t written it down the night I thought of it.
4. Capture the tropes
Tropes are the shorthand of genre fiction. Enemies to lovers, second chances, fake dating, forced proximity, etc. Whatever fits your story. Knowing your tropes early helps shape tone and direction when you return to the project. It’s also a great way to throw out some teasers to your readers-to-be.
5. Sketch a quick outline
If time allows, I’ll write a loose chapter list. It doesn’t need to be perfect or complete. It just needs to be enough to remember where I wanted the story to go. A few bullet points can make all the difference when you revisit the project later.
Why This Works
Writers are idea collectors. It’s part of the job description. But trying to hold every plotline, scene, and character in your head at once can become overwhelming fast. By giving each idea its own “holding space,” you take pressure off your creative mind.
Documenting early ideas gives you permission to relax, knowing that your next projects are waiting safely in the wings. When it’s time to circle back, you’ll have a strong foundation to build on rather than starting from scratch.
Even more, this process keeps your creative flow intact. You’re not shutting down inspiration. You’re organizing it.
A Few Extra Tips for Your Book Ideas
Before you get back to your current manuscript, it helps to have a few practical ways to keep those future story sparks organized. Here are some simple habits that can make managing your book ideas a lot easier.
- Keep an “idea bank.” Whether it’s a notebook, digital folder, or voice memo app, dedicate one space for all your story seeds.
- Revisit your notes monthly. Sometimes what seemed like a throwaway idea might spark something new down the road.
- Don’t judge your early thoughts. Raw notes aren’t meant to be polished—they’re meant to be captured.
- Reward yourself for coming back. Once you’ve jotted down the essentials, return to your current project with a clearer head.
Don’t Let Juggling Multiple Book Ideas Get in Your Way
Juggling multiple story ideas is proof that your creativity is alive and working. The challenge is learning how to manage that inspiration without letting it derail your progress.
So, the next time a new idea interrupts your writing session, don’t panic. Step away for a few minutes, capture the key details, and give your future book a place to live. Then, return to your current manuscript knowing your imagination is safe, organized, and ready for whatever comes next.
Want to hear more about what I’m reading and writing? Sign up for my newsletter today.